So it's pretty common among book readers, but I consider A Feast For Crows (the 4th book, for those that haven't read them) to be the weakest of the five novels. The first three are so tightly written and focused, and Martin really started meandering in books 4 and 5, and due to that they feel very bloated. I feel that 5 is an improvement, but that's really not saying too much.
But I have been torn apart more than once for saying anything negative about this universe, and "how dare I insult the brilliance of GRRM", etc etc. I'm not pretending that I could ever so what he's done, because I can't. But I don't think that anyone can honestly say that book 4 is an improvement on what's come before it. I still love this world, but that doesn't mean it doesn't have room to improve.
What are some criticisms that you've had of the show or books that people have blindly defended, simply because it's part of ASOIAF? And I'm not talking about opinions based things, but things that you feel are valid flaws with the franchise.
Submitted February 26, 2018 at 12:20AM by WhiteWolfofUtah http://ift.tt/2CK142l
No comments:
Post a Comment